GENERAL
ECONOMIC REVIEW | PRIVATE SECTOR DEVELOPMENT
AND CROSS-CUTTING ISSUES| |
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| SPECIAL DEVELOPMENT ISSUE | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
THE
LINKAGE BETWEEN MACRO ECONOMIC PERFORMANCE AND POVERTY SITUATION |
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Introduction
161.
For more than two
decades,
162.
However, the socio–economic
reforms undertaken to date, have enabled
163.
While various macroeconomic indicators
reveal stable growth and significant macroeconomic achievements following
economic and social reforms, some people in the country contend that
the life of ordinary Tanzanian has continued to deteriorate and the
level of poverty has increased. The
aim of this chapter is to try to provide the link between achievement
in macroeconomic indicators and poverty situation in the country.
The Period 1961 - early 1970s
164.
Since independence in 1961, the economy of
The Period 1974 - 1985
165.
Despite the achievements stated above,
the later part of the 1970s started showing signs of an economy in difficulties,
as a result of the rise of oil prices which started in 1973, adverse weather condition
that affected crop output in 1974, collapse of East African Community
in 1977 falling primary commodity prices in the world market, and war
against Uganda’s Iddi Amin in 1978/79.
The socio–economic crisis reached a crimax in the early 1980s
due to shortage of foreign exchange caused by the above listed factors
and the world wide economic recession underway during the time. In order
to reverse the economic situation the country initiated the National
Economic Survival Programmes (NESP) and the Structural Adjustment Programme
(SAP). However, NESP was one
year programme and was replaced by the three year SAP in 1982/83 which
could not be implemented fully because of the extended negotiations
between the Government and the Bretton Woods institutions.
The Period 1986 - 2002
166.
In 1986,
Table
no. 10.1: TRENDS OF SELECTED MACRO ECONOMIC INDICATORS
1995 – 2002
Source: President’s Office, Planning and Privatization Achievements
of Macroeconomic Indicators Growth of GDP
167.
Soon after starting implementation of
various recovery programmes, economic growth began to recover in the
period of 1986 to 1996. In this
period, the economy grew by an average of 3.0 percent.
In the period 1997 to 2002, GDP continued to grow from 3.3 percent
to 6.2 percent. This growth was
attributed to increased production in the sectors of agriculture, industry,
trade, hotels and restaurants (including tourism), and mining. The per capita income increased from shs. 147,134
in 1997 to shs. 256,490 in 2002. Inflation trends
168.
The inflation rate as an indicator of
stable economic growth, has consistently continued
to decline from an average of 21.0 percent in 1996 to 4.5 percent in
2002. The decline in inflation is attributed mainly
to deliberate implementation of fiscal and monetary policies aimed at
controlling government expenditure as well as reducing the increase
in money supply in the country coupled with improvement in food supply
and its availability.
Government Revenue and Expenditure
169.
The government efforts in collecting revenue
continued to improve, whereby more than shs. 100 billion is being collected
per month compared to shs. 25 billion per month in 1995. An increase in revenue collection is due to
improved tax collection and reduction of tax evasion. As regards the expenditure, the Government continued
to improve its expenditure system through Integrated Financial Management
System (IFMS) and establishment of Medium Term Expenditure Framework
(MTEF) as well as cash budget system.
The MTEF system gives priority to sectors identified in the Poverty
Reduction Strategy
(PRS).
Money Supply, Credit and Foreign Reserves
170.
During 1995/996 to 2001/2002, the growth
in broad money supply (M2) continued to decrease from 26.1
percent to 12.3 percent. The
aim is to have growth of money supply that is consistent with economic
growth. The average deposit interest rates provided
by commercial banks declined from 12 percent in 1995/96 to 3.1 percent
in 2002/03. Furthermore, the average lending rate declined from 28.0
percent in 1995/96 to 15.7 percent in 2002/03.
Foreign exchange reserves, the reserve continued to increase
from 3.8 months of imports in 1997 to about 9 months of imports in 2002.
National Debt Stock
171.
Management of national
debt stock has been contributing to strong and stable economic growth.
The national debt stock stood at $ 7,464.0 million at the end of 2001/02,
from $ 7,754.1 million in 1995/96. The
situation reveals that the national debt stock declined by 3.5 percent
in the period between 1995/96 to 2001/02.
The decline of national debt stock provides more opportunities
for the government to allocate resources to priority areas and provision
of quality social services. It may be recalled that
172.
As indicated by macro economic indicators, Poverty Reduction Initiatives
173.
Since independence in 1961, the Government
of Tanzania has been formulating various strategies aimed at alleviating
poverty. The policy regime between 1967 and 1985 was based on socialism
and self-reliance with the state assuming the role of facilitator of
social and economic growth, a standard setter and provider of essential
public services. The national efforts to combat poverty though centrally
directed, resulted in a significant improvement in per capita
income and access to education, health and other social services until
the 1970s. Thereafter, these gains could not be sustained because of
various domestic and external problems as well as policy weaknesses.
In response to the stagnation and reversal in poverty indicators as
well as declining quantity, quality of and access to basic social services,
the government designed comprehensive strategies and articulated a number
of targets in order to arrest the situation. Some of the targets are
derived from international goals while others are national targets set
in a more ambitious implementation timeframe. The key documents that
articulated strategies and targets include Development Vision 2025,
which set the broad development agenda for poverty reduction; the National
Poverty Eradication Strategy (NPES), focusing on poverty targets; the
Tanzania Assistance Strategy (TAS), a framework for directing external
support into priority areas; and the Poverty Reduction Paper (PRSP)
developed in the context of the HIPC initiative, linking targets with
resources allocation and monitoring process as well as strategies for
implementing NPES in the medium term.
174.
However, there are other interventions
to combat abject poverty, which include among others, the Rural Development
Strategy (RDS) and Agricultural Sector Development Strategy (ASDS),
establishment of development funds which are used to facilitate availability
of machinery and inputs, crops procurement, processing, storage, packaging
and modern technology. Some of these funds are Agricultural Input Trust
Fund (AITF), Private Agricultural Sector Support (PASS), and National
Entrepreneur Development Fund as well as Community Trust Fund.
175.
The
emphasis of the Small and Medium Enterprises (SMEs) Policy is on industries
that could be manned and operated by Tanzanians without relying on foreign
technical and financial support, specifically processing of agricultural
and livestock products in order to improve the quality which would enhance
competitiveness both in the regional and international markets, increase
value added, create employment opportunities, and contribute towards
poverty reduction. Furthermore, Micro Finance Policy has provided basis
for establishment of co-operative and community banks, saving and credit
co-operatives as well as civil societies and Non-Governmental Organisations
(NGO’s). These policies have provided favourable and conducive environment
for the private sector participation in productive activities.
176.
As
a way of ensuring availability of technology, capital, and markets for
local investors, the Tanzania Investment Centre (TIC) in collaboration
with the United Nations Industrial Development Organisation (UNIDO)
is implementing identification and promotion exercise for both small
and large local investors. In this exercise a total of 600 small investors
has been identified and assisted in preparing of the project profiles.
177.
The Government established the Tanzania National Business
Council in 2001 chaired by the President of the United Republic of Tanzania.
The outcomes of the dialogues are tax reforms and creation of good governance
and identifying and suggesting remedial measures on investment and trade
bottlenecks. The strategies in place and the starting of
the implementation process has provided signals towards poverty reduction
and improved livelihoods. Current Poverty Status
178.
With all these interventions,
poverty still remains a major hurdle to the Income Poverty
179.
The poverty indicators in the country show that, poverty
is still a major problem facing many people particularly those living
in rural areas. As for the food
poverty, the national rate has declined from 21.6 percent in 1991/92
down to 18.7 percent in 2000/01. Whereas, for the basic needs poverty, the rate
also declined from 38.6 percent in 1991/92 to 35.7 percent in 2000/01. Both two indicators revealed that, it is only
in urban areas that have statistically significant decline rates of
poverty, particularly in Table
No.10.2: POVERTY INDICES IN
Source:
Household Budget Survey 2000/01 Income inequality
180.
The national income inequality index increased by 0.1
percent point from 0.34 percent in 1991/92 to 0.35 percent in 2000/01.
Income inequality has increased at high rate in
Table No. 10.3: INCOME
INEQUALITY MEASURE (GINI COEFFICIENT)
Source: Household Budget Survey 2000/01
Employment
181.
Unemployment rate
is highest in
TABLE NO. 10.4:
UNEMPLOYMENT RATES BY AGE AND BY
GEOGRAPHICAL LOCATION
Source:
Integrated Labour Force Survey survey 2000/01 Non-income poverty
182.
Non-income poverty indicators show slight achievement
in the period between 1991/92 to 2000/01.
As for education, the results of HBS 2000/01 show that, the proportion
of women with education has remained constant at 68 percent from 1991/92.
The proportional distance of children with 2 kilometres from
school has decreased from 66 percent in 1991/92 to 63 percent in 2000/01. As for the illiteracy rate, national statistics
show that 28.6 percent of the total population cannot read and write
in any language. The problem
was found more on women (36 percent) compared to men (20.4 percent),
while for the rural areas the rates is higher compared to urban areas. Enrolment rate in primary schools increased
from 54.2 percent in 1990 to 65.5 percent in 2001.
183.
For the health services, the number of
people accessing health services in different health centres increased
to 66.6 percent in 2000/01 while the proportion of household within
6 kilometres from health facility has remained the same at 75 percent
over the past ten years.
Table
No. 10.5: ILLITERACY
RATES BY SEX AND URBAN-RURAL
Source:
Household Budget Survey 2000/01
184.
The HBS 2000/01 results show that, water services improved
in the urban areas than in rural areas. Whereas 86 percent and 76 percent households
in
185.
As for the housing, there has been significant
increase in quality housing. Houses
with non-earth floor increased from 21 percent in 1991/92 to 26 percent
in 2000/01. The percentage of
households with durable walls increased from 16 percent in 1991/92 to
25 percent in 2000/01. Houses
with concrete and corrugated iron sheet roofs increased from 36 percent
in 1991/92 to 43 percent in 2000/01.
186.
The macroeconomic indicators show the recovery trend
in economic growth. Despite these achievements, the emerging critical
challenge is the low magnitude achieved on poverty reduction efforts
in the country, particularly in most rural areas. It is obvious that, economic growth is still
at lower level to reduce poverty in the country. More efforts are needed to increase production
in all sectors which would provide employment opportunities for majority
of the poor and those sectors which show sustainable growth such as
mining and tourism. Private sector
has become fundamental economic pillar.
The critical concern is to create conducive environment for the
growth of this sector.
LINKAGE BETWEEN MACROECONOMIC PERFORMANCE AND POVERTY SITUATIONMacroeconomic Achievements
187.
Macroeconomic growth is very important for socio-economic
development of any nation. It is very crucial particularly for the poor
nations like
Stability of Price Movements
188.
A
decline in inflation rate is a good indicator for macroeconomic stability
in attracting investors as well as increasing the purchasing power of
the majority of people to acquire goods and services. The growth of
Gross Domestic Product leads to an increase in average per capita income. An increase in per capita income enables people
acquire basic needs, sending children to school, access to health service
and improve their health status, building quality houses and living
in better settlements. As a result of economic reforms, price movements
of goods have continued to decline from 30 percent in 1990 to 4.5 percent
in 2002. The decrease has backed up the purchasing power of the Tanzanian
population, whose majority are poor. Price stability is also an important
element towards poverty reduction resulting from increased production
hence increased Gross Domestic Product and per capita income. Price
stability has been an incentive to local and foreign investors as cost
of production and interest rates are held down. This situation has increased
the volume of trade and hence government tax revenues, which is important
in expenditure directed towards the poor. Increase in Gross Domestic Product
189.
An
increase in Gross Domestic Product is an outcome of economic growth
emanating from upturns in investments and trade, and stability of prices
of goods and services thus augmenting per capita income. Average per
capita income growth was –1.5 percent between 1979
– 1985 and increased to 2 percent between 1986 – 1998. Despite
these, the marginal achievements are good signal to the Tanzanian. Increased
income has enabled the people to acquire socio-economic basic needs
and hence reducing poverty. The increase in Gross Domestic Product has
to go hand in hand with equitable distribution of resources to all Tanzanians.
Money Supply Stability
190.
Improved bank efficiency following the
financial sector reforms has provided opportunities for Tanzanians to
increase owning of securities and capital which enhances production
of goods and services.
Improved bank rates
191.
An interest rate provided by banks is
an indicator of economic growth and social development. An increase in savings deposits rates would
stimulate savings, which is an essential component in capital accumulation. Availability of loans from the banks as well
as reasonable lending rates, will speed up
investment which would accelerate economic growth, and thus reducing
poverty. Improved Exports and Foreign Exchange Earnings
192.
Economic reforms and their achievements
have facilitated the growth of external trade and thus the increase
in foreign reserves. Though not much has been achieved in this aspect,
but what has been done to-date is stabilization of incomes of Tanzanians
and the government in general, thus having an opportunities
to eradicate poverty in the long run. Also, the availability of foreign
currency enables the government and investors to import essential goods
and services for socio–economic development.
Thus, contributing directly to poverty reduction.
Increased Foreign Assistance and Debt Relief
193.
Government achievements in implementing the reform programmes
and achievements in economic growth attained in
Improved Marketing
194.
As a result of economic reform undertaken in
Improved revenue collection and public expenditure
195.
With regard to the various macroeconomic
achievements including, economic growth and stability, improved domestic
revenue collection, increased foreign exchange reserves, declined inflation
rate, and strengthened public financial management, large part of the
government budget has been directed to priority sectors and has been
steadily increasing over the years. The increased budgetary allocations
to the priority areas identified in the Poverty Reduction Strategy has
accelerated economic growth and social services delivery (education,
health, water, judiciary), economic infrastructure services (roads particularly
rural roads) and agriculture.
196.
The Poverty Reduction Strategy identified
six priority sectors for poverty eradication, which, are: education,
water judiciary, health, roads and agriculture. The government has been
implementing poverty eradication initiatives by increasing budgetary
expenditure in those priority sectors using her annual budget through
the Medium Term Expenditure Framework (MTEF) and Public Expenditure
Review (PER) process.
Education
Sector
197.
The government has given priority to the
education sector and the budgetary allocation to the sector has increased
to shs. 414.8 billion in 2002/03 from shs.
164.9 billion in 1998/99, equivalent to an
increase of 151.6 percent. The notable progress in
the sector are due to the increased budgetary allocation to that
sector, together with the formulation and implementation of Education
Sector Development Programme (ESDP) and Primary Education Development
Programme (PEDP). The increased primary school enrolment rate of eligible
school age children and abolition of primary school fees; completion
of primary school mapping exercise in 82 districts in the country; increased
progression rate of primary to secondary schools from 19.5 percent in
2000 to 21.7 percent in 2002; and the government recruitment of 7,277
primary teachers with qualification of grade A, are the results of the
implementation of these programmes. Also, the government continued to
provide training to the teachers in order to impart more skills, and
a total of 2,228 teachers’ houses were constructed and a total of 12,868
new classrooms were constructed in the period 2000 – 2002.
Road
sector
198.
Since 2000/01, when the Poverty Reduction
Strategy started to be implemented, the budgetary allocations in the
road sub-sector have been steadily increasing over years. Rural roads
construction and rehabilitation have been conducted under the President’s
Office, Regional administration and Local Government (PORALG). For instance,
normal and periodic maintenance of 6,599 kilometres of rural roads was
made in 2001/02, and Special Funds for special road projects was established
in order to improve transportation between north-western and southern
regions.
Water
Sector
199.
As a result of increased government budgetary allocation
to water sector, urban water supply services have increased from 68
percent in December 2000 to 73 percent in 2002. The rehabilitation and
expansion of water service supplies was done in Morogoro, Tabora,
Legal
and Judicial Sector
200.
The budget of this sector increased from shs. 5.5 billion
in 1998/99 to shs. 23.8 billion 2002/03, an
increase of 332.7 percent. In 2001/02, 22 resident magistrates, 26 primary
court magistrates and 16 state attorneys were recruited. The
Agriculture
Sector
201.
As a result of increased domestic revenue
collections, budgetary allocation to the agriculture sector through
the Medium Term Expenditure Framework (MTEF) has increased from shs.14.9
billion in 1988/99 to shs. 62.6 billion in
2002/03, equivalent to an increase of 320.1 percent. In 2001, the Agricultural
Sector Development Strategy (ASDS) was approved. Research on agricultural
crops continued to be undertaken in agricultural research institutions.
Various measures for strengthening production and enhancement of agricultural
sector have been undertaken by the government. The measures include
distribution of pesticides to destroy destructive birds and pests, rehabilitation
of irrigation infrastructures in order to enhance sustainable production
of agricultural crops. Some of irrigation projects are River Basin Management
and Smallholder Irrigation Improvement Project (RBMNSIIP) – 1,169 hectares,
Participatory Irrigation Development Programme (PIDP) – 18 schemes were
developed during 2002/03, Agricultural Sector Programme Support (ASPS)
– 5 schemes with a coverage of 3,830 hectares were rehabilitated in
collaboration with respective district councils and small scale irrigation
with a total of 560 hectares were rehabilitated.
Health
Sector
202.
The budgetary allocation to the health
sector has increased from 7.5 percent of the total government budget
in 2000/01 to 8.7 percent in 2002/03. The increased health budgetary
allocation has enhanced and improved health services delivery. The analysis
of health sector performance based on government spending showed that
the absolute level of spending on primary health has increased by 184
percent between 1999/2000 and 2002/03. The disbursed funds to health
sector, particularly primary health is targeted to address health problems
in five priority areas of reproductive and child health, the control
of communicable diseases and strengthening organisational structure
and administration. Various programmes to improve and strengthen health
services delivery have been established and implemented, including National
Project on Malaria Control, Drug Revolving Funds in all district hospitals,
TV and Radio programmes were prepared and disseminated information for
advertising the Health Sector Reform Programme in 2001/02.
HIV/AIDS
203.
The economic impact of HIV/AIDS includes
loss of labour force and productivity, increasing dependence ratio and
the ever-escalated cost to the government for caring and treatment of
infected individuals. In order to control the spread of HIV/AIDS, the
National Multi-sectoral Strategic Framework (NMSF) has been in place
to combat HIV/AIDS. However, the Tanzania Commission for HIV/AIDS (TACAIDS),
was created by the Act of the Parliament in 2001. Notable achievements
of these Strategies to date have been registered. The HIV/AIDS prevalence
rate has decreased from 24 percent in 1994 to 11 percent in 2001. Due
to increased budgetary allocation to the awareness campaign, all sectors
at different levels have had prepared various programmes to contain
the spread of HIV/AIDS. The Ministry of Health in collaboration with
other stakeholders has established a programme to supply and disseminate
relief HIV/AIDS drugs to the affected individuals.
Table
1:
CENTRAL GOVERNMENT EXPENDITURE, 1998/999 – 2002/03
(IN
BILLIONS OF
204.
Those are only few examples, which show how the achievements
in macro-economy are critically important for socio-economic development,
which directly contribute to poverty reduction in any country.
The South East Asian Tigers countries during the 1980’s are classic examples of success story
in the linkage between macroeconomic achievement and poverty reduction. Indeed, the pending great challenge for
CONCLUSION AND THE WAY FORWARD
205.
206.
Achievements
attained as a result of economic reforms in the country have caused
a stable economy and sustainable growth.
However, the achievements have not fully enabled to significantly
improve the living conditions especially for the people in rural areas
and those with low incomes. In
order for these achievements to reach the majority of people and improve
their living standards, efforts must be continued and directed at the
following important areas:
·
Reform in agriculture sector that will
provide employment for majority of people particularly those living
in rural areas, especially through application of modern technology
and irrigation in small scale and large scale farms as major
avenue of agriculture transformation from rain-fed agriculture.
Furthermore, modern technology is required in developing agriculture
sector.
·
Promote and develop small and micro enterprises
which would to include; processing of traditional commodities; small-scale
industries; and provision of various services. complementary efforts
are required in provision of credits (micro-finance) and to develop
entrepreneurship skills for various groups of production enterprises
and service delivery.
·
Further tax reform to lighten the tax
burden for farmers particularly small scale farmers, and to improve
tax administration.
·
Strengthening of economic infrastructure
such as roads, particularly rural roads to support the development of
agricultural sector and consolidate the domestic market, and for exports.
·
Further review of Land Act and the underlying
policy and regulations, in order to address concerns relating to the
use of land as collateral for bank lending.
·
Create
a mindset for development and working hard in the society in order to
move away from dependency mindset. |
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||